Review (and a Giveaway!): The Imposter by Suzanne Woods Fisher

Posted March 26, 2016 by meezcarrie in Amish, Christian, contemporary, giveaway, Suzanne Woods Fisher / 6 Comments


Blog Tour Stops

March 22: Quiet Quilter

March 23: Singing Librarian Books

March 23: Heidi Reads…

March 24: Splashes of Joy

March 24: Mary Hake

March 25: cherylbbookblog

March 25: The Power of Words

March 26: Reading Is My SuperPower

March 26: Just Commonly

March 27: Giveaway Lady

March 27: D’S QUILTS & BOOKS

March 27: Cassandra M’s Place

March 28: Through The Open Window

March 28: Lane Hill House

March 28: Marilyn Ridgeway

March 29: Daysong Reflections

March 29: Rhonda’s Doings

March 29: Debbie Dusty Deliberatons

March 30: A Greater Yes

March 30: Diana’s Tea Time Reviews

March 30: Simple Harvest Reads

March 31: Texas Book-aholic

March 31: A Holland Reads

April 1: Blessed and Bewildered

April 1: Bukwurmzzz

April 2: Southern Gal Loves to Read

April 2: For The Love of Books

April 3: Book Bites, Bee Stings, and Butterfly Kisses

April 3: Blossoms and Blessings

April 4: Books! Books! Books!

Guest Post from Suzanne Woods Fisher

If you think you have a pretty clear idea of what an Amish bishop is like—stern, authoritative, patriarchal?—have another think. David Stoltzfus in The Imposter is warm, kindhearted, a reluctant farmer, and quite attractive!

Sound like an unlikely character for an Amish novel? Maybe so, but David Stoltzfus is modeled after a bishop I met, years ago. This real-life bishop might be the most intelligent, thoughtful, spiritually sensitive, and well-read man I’ve ever met. We spent a morning talking Bonhoeffer in his Spartan living room, warmed by his woodstove.

I wanted to present the character of a bishop that best represented this man I’d grown to admire. So when it was time to create a proposal for a new series, I suggested ‘The Bishop’s Family,’ staring David Stoltzfus who was loosely based on this particular bishop.

Very loosely.

David Stoltzfus is a handsome, widowed father of six who runs a local bulk food store. His children are surprisingly nonconforming, outspoken, and fiercely protective of their clan. The real-life bishop is a farmer, happily married with four independently minded children, and looks…well, to be candid, he looks a little like Benjamin Franklin.

But here’s what they have in common: they both love to read, they love their families, and they love the work God has given them of tending a flock.

The Imposter begins as David Stoltzfus moves his family to Stoney Ridge for a fresh start, a new beginning. Things don’t start off well: his eldest daughter, Katrina, faces a crushing disappointment, his prodigal son Jesse has a bent for troublemaking, and then David realizes something fishy is going on in the little church.

A new life awaits the Stoltzfus family, but not the one they expected. Or wanted. But they are needed in Stoney Ridge, each one of them. Even Jesse. 🙂

I hope you’ll feel as though you’ve made some new friends as you get to know David and his children. One thing I can promise: this bishop’s family will surprise you.

Happy Reading!

Warmly, Suzanne

Book Information

the imposterA heart once deceived should not be easily fooled again . . .

Katrina Stoltzfus thought she had life and love all figured out: she was going to marry John and live happily ever after. But as her plans crumble before her eyes, she struggles to face an uncertain future. When a widow asks for help starting a new business, Katrina quickly agrees. She needs time to heal her broken heart, to untangle her messy life, to find a purpose.

What she doesn’t need is attention from Andy Miller, a farmhand who arrives at the widow’s farm just when help is most needed–and who always seems to say the right thing and be in the right place, at the right time. Is Andy for real or too good to be true? She’s been deceived once before, and she isn’t planning on experiencing it again.

my thoughts

Suzanne Woods Fisher writes the kind of Amish fiction I love to read. Charming but realistic characters (flaws and all!), humor, heart, and truth I can apply to my own life.

From the opening lines of the prologue – “Surprises come in two shapes – good and bad. This one, though, felt indeterminate.” – I was hooked by Suzanne’s writing voice. She weaves subtle humor between profound truths and packages it all in an engaging style that keeps readers absorbed from cover to cover.

As the story unfolded further and I met each character, I quickly fell in love with Stoney Ridge and its residents. (The author has written other books set in this community, but this series stands alone. I have not read the other books – yet – but didn’t feel my understanding of this particular book was impeded in any way by this lack of pre-knowledge.) David Stoltzfus is my favorite character in The Imposter – followed very closely by Hank Lapp whom Fisher wrote with on-point comedic timing.  David is full of wisdom, discernment, and faith… and his insights are worth writing down and keeping close for future reference! And then there’s Birdy, in all her endearing clumsiness … Katrina, with her heartbroken courage … Jesse, and his bigger-than-his-age vocabulary… spunky, independent Thelma … the other Stoltzfus children full of personality … and handsome, dog-adopting, widow-protecting, Katrina-befriending, book-boyfriend-becoming Andy.  Each character in The Imposter adds strength to the novel in his/her own way and ensures that readers will be waiting impatiently for the next installment in the series!

Speaking of next installments 😉 while a thread or two of this particular storyline was tied up nicely by the end of the book, there are still several open-ended subplots going on that left me gobbling up the teaser preview for The Quieting included in the back. Argh. Is it May yet? Because I really need to know what’s going on with the folks in Stoney Ridge!

Bottom Line: If you’re like me and prefer your Amish fiction to have some realistic flaws to its characters – without sacrificing their charm – then you will enjoy The Imposter.  The cleverly-selected title, which could be applied to any number of people in Stoney Ridge, adds yet another dimension to the talented writing style evident throughout.  The reminder to let God write your story is one that anybody – Amish, non-Amish, even someone just curious about Jesus – can embrace and take to heart.  Fans of Shelley Shepard Gray will find another author to love in Suzanne Woods Fisher – and readers will be eagerly counting down the days until The Quieting’s release & the chance to catch up with these new friends.

(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)

My Rating: 4 stars / Loved it! 

Author Information


Suzanne Woods Fisher is an award-winning, bestselling author whose most recent novels include Anna’s Crossing and The Inn at Eagle Hill series, as well as nonfiction books about the Amish, including Amish Peace and The Heart of the Amish. She lives in California. Learn more at and follow Suzanne on Twitter @suzannewfisher.



Suzanne is graciously giving away a Kindle Fire 7! Click below to enter!


Tags: , ,

6 responses to “Review (and a Giveaway!): The Imposter by Suzanne Woods Fisher

  1. Thanks so much for your write-up of “Imposter.” I’m thrilled you liked David (and Hank! One of my faves), as well as the title of the book, too! (It was my suggestion! Usually my titles get the axe.) Grateful to be on your blog! Warmly, Suzanne

Leave a Reply