Book Review (and a Giveaway!): Their Daring Hearts by Sharlene MacLaren

Posted January 29, 2018 by meezcarrie in Christian, giveaway, historical, romance, Sharlene MacLaren / 21 Comments

about the book

Levi Albright rebelled against his Quaker roots to fight for abolition in the Union army in the first year of the Civil War. Two years later, 19-year-old destitute orphan Josephine Winters, with her chopped hair, boy’s clothes, and new name, “Snipp,” enlists in the Union army out of desperation.

Just over five feet tall and barely weighing as much as a newborn calf, Snipp seems to Levi to be barely old enough to hold “his” gun. But despite being teased by the regiment, Snipp quickly earns admiration for skill with a musket and unequaled bravery. When Levi explains one night that he is a Quaker leading a regiment, it leads to a late-night discussion of faith and a developing friendship.

But Snipp’s secret can only be hidden for so long. After an injury forces Josie to reveal her real identity, Levi is angered by her deception. Worse, Josie is marched out of the company without a chance to explain—or even say goodbye. Will their friendship survive? Or will the hatred saturating the war-torn nation affect even the heart of a peace-loving Quaker?

goodreads button RIMSP

SERIES: Forever Freedom #2
GENRE: Inspirational Historical Fiction
PUBLISHER: Whitaker House
RELEASE DATE: January 9, 2018
PAGES: 336

Other Books In This Series

“…some things are worth fighting for, and freedom is one of them.”

I really enjoyed this book, y’all. For several reasons.

Image Source: Pinterest

First, it’s set during the Civil War (one of my favorite time periods to read about because of such great courage shown by people fighting for the freedom of others), but it’s also about two unlikely soldiers. A Quaker and a woman, both passionate enough about the cause to risk everything to fight for the Union Army. Levi is going against his religion and his family, though his family loves him anyway & respects his choice. But I can imagine it was not at all an easy decision for him to make. Josie (aka Gordon Snipp) is going against the law, against society, and against her own body to fight now that her brother cannot. I cannot fathom what it would be like a) to disguise your true gender in those conditions and b) to face the horrors of war so young. I have long admired the accounts of women who disguised themselves as boys and fought in the Civil War – what great courage! Oh that I could be as strong today as they were then.

Second, there’s a deliciously-written suspense thread woven throughout the story. MacLaren does a great job of keeping the reader suspicious of several suspects without giving too much away. And the revelation of the traitor’s identity may surprise you! The bitterness and growing madness of the spy among them is palpable as the author writes occasionally from his perspective, creating little vignettes inside his mind that heighten the book’s tension even further.

I also really enjoyed the bits of humor and faith that kept the story from being too heavy. The gruesomeness of war, the illnesses that sweep through the camp, the emotions driving both Levi and Josie… it hits you heavy in the heart. But peppered throughout, at just the right moments, are cute scenes of soldier camaraderie and groan-worthy jokes told around a fire. Not only does it put a smile on your face, but it also nicely alleviates that heaviness. Likewise, the gentle spiritual conversations that Levi has with dying and/or wounded soldiers – as well as ‘Gordon’ – wrap around your heart like a warm hug. The gospel – the fact that none of us is good enough but Jesus stands in our place, loves us, and has a plan for us – is clearly presented more than once but avoids feeling as though the story has stopped for a sermon.

But my favorite part of the novel is (you guessed it) the romance. The fact that Levi and Josie begin as friends (because of course Levi only knows her as ‘Gordon Snipp’), and that their friendship deepens throughout the course of the novel, makes the tentative progression into romance (once Levi discovers Josie’s true identity) sweet and tender. And that first kiss is … whew. It’s well worth the wait!

Bottom Line: Their Daring Hearts by Sharlene MacLaren is intriguing, well-written and layered. The characters come alive on the pages, marching right into your heart and setting up camp. This is not just a story of the Civil War. It’s also not just a story of a Quaker deciding to fight for freedom or of a young woman deciding to join the Union Army in a boy’s disguise. It’s a story of friendship, forgiveness and courage – all three in the face of the worst conditions. This is truly an inspiring and educational read as well as being entertaining!

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.)

My Rating: 4 stars / Love it!

KissingBook Level: 3 / May forget to breathe on occasion

amazon button RIMSP B&N button RIMSP

about the author

Born and raised in western Michigan, Sharlene MacLaren graduated from Spring Arbor University then traveled nationally with a contemporary Christian vocal ensemble. She married Cecil, with whom she’d grown up in Spring Arbor, and the couple had two daughters. Shar embarked on a teaching career that would span over 30 years. As she contemplated retirement, Shar sought God’s guidance, praying for a vocation that would provide the kind of fulfillment and joy she experienced as a teacher and mother. A lifelong gifted story teller, she began to write Christian romance novels. Her first book, Through Every Storm, published in 2007, was met with critical acclaim and brisk sales. The rest, as they say, is history. Whitaker House’s bestselling fiction author, she’s subsequently published 18 books, mostly historical romances. Shar enjoys reading, singing in her church choir and worship team, traveling, and spending time with her husband, children, and grandchildren. She’s very interactive on Facebook and Twitter. For more:,, Twitter @ sharzy_lu.

Other Books by Sharlene MacLaren

To celebrate her tour, Whitaker House is giving away:

Grand Prize Package: Their Daring Hearts (Forever Freedom Series) #2 by Sharlene MacLaren; Summer on Sunset Ridge (Forever Freedom Series #1) signed by the author, Sharlene MacLaren, Abba Jerusalem Hyssop 6” Pillar Candle.
1st Place: Their Daring Hearts (Forever Freedom Series) #2 by Sharlene MacLaren; Heart of Mercy (Tennessee Dreams #1) by Sharlene MacLaren; Whitaker House/Anchor Coloring Book with Colored Pencils.
2nd Place: Their Daring Hearts (Forever Freedom Series) #2 by Sharlene MacLaren; Whitaker House/Anchor Coloring Book with Colored Pencils.!!

Click below to enter. Be sure to comment on this post before you enter to claim 9 extra entries!

[promosimple id=”c602″]

This giveaway is hosted by Celebrate Lit, not RimSP
Follow along with the tour for more chances to win!

Tags: , ,

21 responses to “Book Review (and a Giveaway!): Their Daring Hearts by Sharlene MacLaren

  1. Kay Garrett

    Thank you for your wonderful review on “Their Daring Hearts” by Sharlene MacLaren and for being part of the book tour.

    It sounds like a marvelous book and one I’ve very much love to read.

  2. Audrey Stewart

    I am so glad to read that there is a new book out by Sharlene. My favorite book of hers was Through Every Storm. I read that, and then I was hooked. I am such a big fan of hers.

  3. Jeanne C

    New author to me and new series! Would love to read it! Thanks for the opportunity to win.

    Just a quick note-went to Sharlene’s FB page and got this response “Sharlene has reached the friend limit. She can’t receive friend requests right now.”

    I guess that’s a good problem to have 😉

  4. Winnie Thomas

    Great review, Carrie! I love historical fiction, and this book sounds intriguing. I’m going to have to put it in my ever-growing pile. 😀

  5. Janice Moore

    I also enjoy reading about the courage shown during this time, and when young ladies hide their identities in desperate situations, it is icing on the cake!

  6. Natalya Lakhno

    Snipp’s story touched my heart already by reading this review and blurb about the book. Thank you, I’ve really enjoyed reading it 🙂
    The book is an addition to TBR list.

  7. Vivian Furbay

    I really want to see how this story ends. This girl sure had the courage to dress as a boy and fight in the civil war what with all the evil things that happened.

  8. Janet Estridge

    We have Sharlene’s books in the church library. We are friends not only on Facebook but in “real” life.
    Thanks for entering me in your giveaway.

  9. Dianne Casey

    Really enjoyed the description of the book. The Civil War era is one of my favorite time periods to read about. Looking forward to reading the book.

  10. Debbie Clatterbuck

    Their Daring Hearts sounds so intriguing. I can’t wait to read it. Thanks for the giveaway and good luck everyone.

Leave a Reply